Feature Request #3393
delete 'Packaging Rrequest' as valid redmine 'Issue Concern' (aka: Tracker)
0%
Description
I'll list why I attempted to package each one along with the link to the list message:
- GMID: marked out of date on Nov.4: https://lists.parabola.nu/pipermail/dev/2022-November/008367.html
- Finger client (netkit BSD), no finger clients available in Parabola: https://lists.parabola.nu/pipermail/dev/2022-November/008370.html
- Naemon - system monitor for servers: https://lists.parabola.nu/pipermail/dev/2022-November/008373.html
- OpenSMTPd-extras - a collection of small programs and scripts useful for running OpenSMTPd: https://lists.parabola.nu/pipermail/dev/2022-December/008387.html
- wlr-randr - xrandr for wayland WMs using wlroots (no such solution currently exists in the repos): https://lists.parabola.nu/pipermail/dev/2022-December/008388.html
- yambar - lightweight X11 and wayland bar, written in C: https://lists.parabola.nu/pipermail/dev/2022-December/008391.html
All of the new packages, I am willing to take it upon myself to be the maintainer and make sure that the PKGBUILDs get updated on time and tested.
Related issues
History
Updated by bill-auger over 1 year ago
the dev list really is the best attended communication channel - most parabola devs do not watch the bug tracker, forum, IRC, or the pagure repo; but most active and inactive devs read the dev list
Updated by wael over 1 year ago
I didn't get a comment on most of them or if they are even appropriate to package so I assumed they fell between the cracks, good to know though that the list is more relevant than here.
Updated by wael over 1 year ago
About wlr-randr: it can be skipped, as I've managed to replicate the same behavior by using kanshi instead (which is already in the repos) - I will try to document it though in the wiki, as even the project's official docs are a bit lacking.
Updated by bill-auger over 1 year ago
packaging requests take so long because they are time consuming - some are dreaded, eg: yet another un-reproducible webby contraption or AUR-dep rabbit-hole - i just checked, of the 411 packaging requests on the bug tracker, 187 were completed or rejected - what parabola needs is a triage and/or licensing teams to process all the incoming packaging requests, patches, and freedom bugs, manage the blacklist, pagure pull-requests, etc
Updated by wael over 1 year ago
bill-auger wrote:
packaging requests take so long because they are time consuming - some are dreaded, eg: yet another un-reproducible webby contraption or AUR-dep rabbit-hole - i just checked, of the 411 packaging requests on the bug tracker, 187 were completed or rejected - what parabola needs is a triage and/or licensing teams to process all the incoming packaging requests, patches, and freedom bugs, manage the blacklist, pagure pull-requests, etc
I do understand and greatly appreciate the effort that goes into maintaining Parabola overall!
In the case of gmid, I would like to point out that the attached PKGBUILD is a point update to an already existing package, that has been sitting for over a month - meanwhile unifont got updated much faster. This is what lead me to thinking some of these might've not been noticed.
As for the rest, this isn't merely a regular package request - in all of those I've attached PKGBUILDs that were vetted with libremakepkg and where I personally went ahead and checked the licenses (for the sake of accuracy, naemon is the only one I didn't properly vet - and I should've pointed that out).
As for the software itself, almost all of these are written in C and are generally small programs with minimal dependencies (all the dependencies are already in Parabola's repos).
But again, as I said earlier, the only one that really surprised me was gmid - since it is a minor update and not a wholly new package.
Updated by bill-auger about 1 year ago
- Related to Bug #3426: Package updates on the mailing list added
Updated by bill-auger about 1 year ago
- Subject changed from Packaging requests on the mailing list to delete 'Packaging Rrequest' as valid redmine 'Issue Concern' (aka: Tracker)
- Project changed from Packages to Servers
- Tracker changed from Bug to Feature Request
In the case of gmid, that has been sitting for over a month - meanwhile unifont got updated much faster.
no reason - i just chose one of the ~20 or so since january - IIRC gnutoo chose another