Project

General

Profile

Freedom Issue #3217

[xonotic-data] No license

gap - 6 months ago - . Updated 6 months ago.

Status:
info needed
Priority:
bug
Assignee:
-
% Done:

0%


Description

This truly is a sad day. I considered Xonotic to be a top-tier example of a libre game.

The data files are hosted on Gitlab and at least the data, maps, and music `.pk3`s have no license and as such are proprietary.

I seriously hope this is a mistake of forgetting to properly license the files in question. Losing Xonotic would be such a shame.

History

#1

Updated by GNUtoo 6 months ago

The PKGBUILD has the following:

license=('GPL')

So that means GPLv2 or later. The question here is if that license information is right or not.

That PKGBUILD downloads the release of Xonotic:

source=("https://dl.xonotic.org/xonotic-${pkgver}.zip")

And it then uses some of its content to make a package:

package() {
  [...]
  mv $srcdir/Xonotic/data $pkgdir/usr/share/xonotic/

  # server stuff
  cp -r $srcdir/Xonotic/server $pkgdir/usr/share/xonotic/

  # key
  install -Dm644 key_0.d0pk $pkgdir/usr/share/xonotic/key_0.d0pk
}

And the COPYING has that:

Contributions
-------------

By committing data/files, you agree to license all the changes/additions
contained in your commits to Team Xonotic under the terms of the General Public
License version 2, with the "any later version" clause active. In particular,
you guarantee that you have acquired all the necessary rights from possible
other copyright holders to be able to license your work under this license. Any
submission which does not fulfill this condition may lead to legal action
against the submitter.

Exceptions however may be made on request, but in any case, Team Xonotic must
be allowed to distribute the changes as part of the git repository, and others
must be allowed to redistribute it in form of cloned git repositories. As
stated above, no guarantees are made by Team Xonotic about licensing status of
such branches.

So we can assume (for now) that the files are under GPLv2 or later.

In the data directory we have some pk3 files. That is just some zip files.

Do you have the link to the repositories that lack any licenses?

Do you know if some of the files in the data repositories are also in the pk3 files?

#2

Updated by GNUtoo 6 months ago

  • Status changed from unconfirmed to info needed
#3

Updated by gap 6 months ago

https://gitlab.com/xonotic/xonotic-data.pk3dir
https://gitlab.com/xonotic/xonotic-maps.pk3dir
https://gitlab.com/xonotic/xonotic-music.pk3dir

Above are three of the .pk3 repos, all of which have no license in the repos themselves, and have files which end up in the package.

https://gitlab.com/xonotic/mediasource

I missed this repo before, which appears to have the sources for all the media in the above repos, so it does indeed appear to be a mistake of missing the license file in the above repos. A cursory glance also seemed to reveal the sources all use libre formats usable by free software, although a more in-depth audit would be required to ensure there are no proprietary media files embedded within those project files.

Also available in: Atom PDF